A List of The Best Seafood Dishes at Timoti’s Seafood Shak

The results are in! Timoti’s most popular seafood dishes have been ranked. At Timoti’s, we pride ourselves on providing locals and visitors alike with simple, flavorful meals made with wild-caught seafood and fresh ingredients.

Join us as we walk through the favorite menu items at one of Fernandina Beach’s best seafood spots. Find out what keeps our customers coming back for more. Seafood lovers beware: you may become very hungry while reading this.

#5 Shrimp Tacos

We’ve got the perfect dish for your next Taco Tuesday. Our shrimp tacos feature freshly prepared shrimp that is cooked to perfection and served in warm tortillas with a vibrant mix of fresh toppings. Choose whether you want your shrimp blackened or grilled and satisfy your taste buds.

If you’re looking to add a little more spice, then we suggest getting blackened shrimp. At Timoti’s, we use our own signature blend to achieve the most perfect crust. These tacos could be your next 10 out of 10 meal.

#4 Baja Box

As one of T’s Faves, we had to include our Baja Box on the best-of-the-best list. The base of this dish is coconut rice with avocado, greens, black bean salsa and tomatoes with tangy cilantro ranch.

Fish complements this meal as a tasty, lean protein option that leaves consumers feeling properly fueled and content (thank you to those omega-3s!). Not in the mood for fish? No problem — choose from shrimp, chicken or tofu instead. Customers rave about this menu item, noting its bold and refreshing taste.

#3 Lobster Rolls

Lobster rolls are a New England staple, known for their fresh lobster meat, simple presentation and delicious taste. Timoti’s lobster rolls feature our chilled lobster salad served in two New England-style rolls — or as a wrap.

Customers describe our lobster rolls as overflowing with sweet lobster, minimal filler and a great roll. Enjoy luxurious lobster in the palm of your hand!

#2 Shrimp Basket

Who can resist a classic shrimp basket? It’s a fried favorite! At Timoti’s expect a generous portion of shrimp fried to a crispy golden brown. Plus, our shrimp basket comes with fries, slaw and hush puppies.

If fried shrimp isn’t your cup of tea, you can choose to get your shrimp blackened or grilled. And don’t forget a yummy dipping sauce like tartar or cocktail.

#1 Poke Bowl

Drum roll please…number one on the list is the adventurous Poke Bowl! In this fresh and flavorful dish, you’ll enjoy raw Ahi tuna, coconut rice, avocado, spinach, green onions, kelp seasoning and black sesame seeds with T’s poke sauce. Talk about the perfect blend of ingredients.

If you think our poke bowl looks appetizing, you can bet it tastes even better. And if you just can't get enough, you can double the tuna for $3.00 (yes, please).

Taste These Best-Selling Meals at Timoti’s in Fernandina Beach

Is your mouth watering from imagining all of these tasty seafood dishes? Visit Timoti’s Seafood Shak to try your number one choice today.

From Shrimp Tacos to Lobster Rolls: Timoti’s Most Popular Seafood Items Ranked